Why Traditional SCA Cannot Keep Up With AI-Generated Code

By

7 minute read time

Why Traditional SCA Cannot Keep Up With AI-Generated Code
8:42
Image with a computer monitor icon on the left side, magnifying glass icon at center, and code terminal notification icons on the right side.

AI coding tools generate and revise code in seconds. They can also make dependency decisions along the way in selecting packages and versions, adding frameworks, or changing how an application uses existing components.

Each choice becomes part of the software supply chain and adds something teams need to evaluate. Many traditional software composition analysis (SCA) workflows assess those choices after they enter the codebase when a pull request or build triggers a scan.

As AI tools introduce or modify dependencies more frequently, that scan-and-review process can lag behind development.

SCA remains essential for understanding and managing the components in software. But to keep pace with AI-assisted development, teams need to pair scanning with up-to-date component intelligence and policy guidance at the point where developers and AI tools choose dependencies.

AI Adds More Dependency Decisions to Every Change

AI-generated code is often discussed in terms of whether or not it contains vulnerabilities. That is only part of the security picture. An AI coding tool can introduce a package, select a version, or modify an existing dependency, often faster than developers can review them individually.

In traditional SCA workflows, that analysis begins after a dependency has been selected: a developer adds a package, a pull request or build triggers a scan, and the team reviews the findings. That approach can work when component changes arrive at a pace people can absorb. It becomes harder when coding assistants and agents generate changes continuously, sometimes introducing several dependencies in a single task.

The more dependency decisions AI makes, the more important it is that each choice is based on reliable, current information. Without that context, unsuitable packages or versions can add risk, review, and remediation work downstream.

AI Recommendations Need Current Context

A model's knowledge may not reflect current package releases, vulnerabilities, licensing details, or project health.

Without that context, it may:

  • Suggest an outdated version when a more current release is available.

  • Recommend a package or version that does not exist.

  • Choose a component that conflicts with organizational policies or license requirements.

Developers and AI tools need current component intelligence to evaluate those choices. We explain how to bring that context into AI-assisted workflows in our guidance on safer development.

A dependency graph can also grow beyond the package a developer sees in a code suggestion. A direct dependency may bring in transitive components, and a project may span several languages or ecosystems.

In our recent analysis of AI and shift-left security, we compared a Spring Framework project with 764 open source components in its dependency tree to an agentically developed project with 2,543 dependencies across four languages. These examples do not represent every project, but they illustrate how quickly the review surface can expand.

The result is not simply "more code," but a larger, changing dependency surface that teams must evaluate, often with less time and visibility.

Why Scan-and-Review Can Become a Bottleneck

A scan can identify a vulnerable or policy-violating component, but detection is only the start of the work.

Teams still need to determine if the finding applies to their use, how urgent it is, whether or not an acceptable alternative exists, and how to update without breaking the application. If every new finding requires an individual investigation, a faster development workflow can create a longer security queue.

Several gaps tend to emerge:

  • The decision has already been made. A scan in a pull request or CI pipeline may flag a component after it has been added to the code. The team now needs to remove or replace it, potentially reworking code that depends on it.

  • Finding volume grows faster than review capacity. More dependency changes can generate more alerts. If teams cannot distinguish urgent exposure from lower-priority findings, important work competes with routine triage.

  • The scan may lack decision context. A result tells the team that a component has a risk, but developers also need current information about versions, maintenance, licenses, and organizational policies to choose a suitable alternative.

  • Manual review does not scale with automated changes. Security teams and maintainers cannot review every dependency choice one by one when assistants and agents can produce many changes across teams and repositories.

  • Late remediation creates rework. Replacing a dependency after implementation or testing may require code changes, new tests, and another round of review. That can erase some of the time AI saved during initial development.

These pressures reflect the AI productivity paradox in which speeding up code creation does not automatically speed up review, testing, security, or release. If those stages cannot absorb the additional volume, more output can mean more work waiting in queues.

Move Component Guidance Closer to the Choice

Rather than waiting for a scan to run, teams can give developers and AI coding tools and AI systems current component intelligence as they choose dependencies.

That guidance should help answer practical questions before a dependency becomes part of an application:

  • Does this component and version exist, and is it maintained?

  • Are there known vulnerabilities or malware concerns?

  • What license does it use, and does it meet the organization's licensing requirements?

  • Does the choice meet the organization's policies?

  • Is there a safer or more suitable version that is compatible with the application?

AI tools need that information in a form they can use during development. That lets them check component details as they make recommendations.

This does not remove the need for developer judgment. Teams still need to set policies, review exceptions, and understand how dependencies are used. The goal is to give developers and AI tools reliable information to make better initial choices and reduce the number of avoidable issues that reach a later review queue.

Keep Scanning as Part of a Layered Approach

Earlier guidance and later-stage analysis solve different problems. AI-assisted development calls for safeguards across the SDLC. Context at the point of choice can prevent some risky or noncompliant dependencies from entering a codebase.

Automated workflows can also update dependencies or prepare changes for developer review. SCA scans remain important for identifying issues in existing applications, surfacing newly disclosed vulnerabilities, and helping teams respond as component risk changes.

Modern SCA can extend beyond scanning with component intelligence and policy guidance at selection, along with automation for dependency updates and remediation.

A practical workflow:

  • Gives developers and AI coding tools access to current component and vulnerability information.

  • Applies organizational policies consistently across human and AI-assisted development.

  • Offers clear alternatives and remediation guidance when a recommendation raises concerns.

  • Continues scanning code and builds to catch problems that earlier controls miss.

  • Maintains an accurate view of application dependencies so teams can assess impact when new risks emerge.

This approach keeps security controls close to development without turning every change into a manual approval process. It also recognizes that no single scan or decision point can account for every risk throughout a component's lifecycle.

Build at AI Speed With Better Dependency Decisions

AI can make software development faster, but every new component still raises questions about security, maintenance, licensing, and policy. When teams answer those questions only after a scan or review, that added speed can create more triage and rework.

To keep pace, teams need SCA that goes beyond scanning to guide dependency selection and support ongoing management and remediation.

Sonatype Guide is an AI SCA platform that connects developers and AI agents to real-time open source intelligence and policy guidance. It helps them choose trusted components, automate dependency upgrades, govern open source risk, and maintain software transparency across the AI SDLC.

Explore Sonatype Guide to see how your teams can make informed dependency decisions earlier in AI-assisted development.

Picture of Aaron Linskens

Written by Aaron Linskens

Aaron is a technical writer at Sonatype. He works at a crossroads of technical writing, developer advocacy, and information design. He aims to get developers and non-technical collaborators to work better together in solving problems and building software.

Tags